Florian BRUNIAUX
|
c28161dca8
|
docs: enrich RTK evaluation with T3 Stack production testing
Real-World Testing Results (Méthode Aristote - T3 Stack):
- Project: Next.js 15 + tRPC + Prisma + pnpm
- Commands tested: 12 (git, pnpm, Vitest, TypeScript, Prisma)
- Git workflows validated: 85.6% avg reduction (up from 72.6%)
Critical Bug Discovered:
- git argument parsing broken (`--oneline`, `--graph` blocked)
- Workaround: `rtk git log -- -20` (works)
- Impact: CRITICAL - affects ALL git users
Modern Stack Gaps Identified:
- pnpm support MISSING (80-90% reduction possible, CRITICAL impact)
- Vitest support MISSING (90% reduction possible, HIGH impact)
- TypeScript support MISSING (70% reduction possible, MEDIUM impact)
ROI Analysis:
- Current v0.2.0: 40% command coverage, 55% token reduction
- Proposed v0.3.0 (pnpm + Vitest): 85% coverage, 80% reduction
- Dev effort: 1 week (7 days)
New Deliverables:
- Benchmark script: examples/scripts/rtk-benchmark.sh (reproductible tests)
- Test results: claudedocs/rtk-test-results-aristote.md (53KB, gitignored)
- Updated PR proposals: claudedocs/rtk-pr-proposals.md (P0-P2 ranking)
- GitHub issues: claudedocs/rtk-github-issue-template.md (ready for upstream)
Updated Evaluation:
- Score: Still 4/5 (GOOD) but clearer path to 5/5 (CRITICAL)
- Blockers: git args bug + pnpm/Vitest gaps
- Strength: 85.6% git reduction validated on production codebase
Full report: claudedocs/rtk-test-results-aristote.md (23K detailed analysis)
|
2026-01-28 14:01:37 +01:00 |
|